Skip to product information

Our new cheesecakes are bigger and better than ever! Our cheesecakes feature a buttery graham cracker crust, a smooth and sweet filling, and are topped with a bit of flair! Current flavors: Lemon + NY Style

2.5" cheesecakes

Regular price
$5.00
Unit price
 per 
Cheesecake (Multiple Flavors Available)
  • Quantity: Single
  • Flavor: NY Style

artisan small pastries

Our small pastries at Butterfly Bakery are meant to delight and impress. Each pastry is made in store by our skilled bakers. Our small pastry menu rotates seasonally.

There's More to enjoy

  • Cannoli with Chocolate Curls

    Cannoli with Chocolate Curls

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Cheesecake (Multiple Flavors Available)

    Cheesecake (Multiple Flavors Available)

    Regular price
    From $5.00
    Unit price
     per 
  • Vanilla Petit Four

    Vanilla Petit Four

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Gluten Friendly Peanut Butter Bon Bons

    Gluten Friendly Peanut Butter Bon Bons

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Classic Cream Puff

    Classic Cream Puff

    Regular price
    From $5.00
    Unit price
     per 
  • Vanilla Eclair

    Vanilla Eclair

    Regular price
    From $5.00
    Unit price
     per 
  • Witch Fingers

    Witch Fingers

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Chocolate Petit Four

    Chocolate Petit Four

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Chocolate Macaron

    Chocolate Macaron

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • Apple Pie Macaron

    Apple Pie Macaron

    Regular price
    From $3.50
    Unit price
     per 
  • View all